Is Sinful Colors Georgio and dupe for Orly's Naughty?

So with the recent shoulder issue, I decided some much needed swatching needed to happen! So, I sat down last night and had a swatch fest. In the process I came across 2 colors that had been in my collection for a little while, and realized that they were the same, or at least looked it..

So here's 2 coats of each. The caption under the photos will tell you which color is on which nail. The picture is 2 coats, no top coat.

Pinky and Middle are Orly's Naughty, Ring and Index are Sinful Colors Georgio

So they're not EXACT dupes, but I couldn't tell the difference until I took the picture with the flash. Georgio is a bit more brown than Naughty, but they're SO similar, I'm gonna say that Georgio is a dupe for Naughty.

In other shoulder news, I found out yesterday that I did NOT tear my rotater cuff! I can't even begin to express how happy that makes me! I did however bruise the tissue. My doctor said, "You didn't tear it, but it is massively bruised. I'm saying massively because saying moderate to severe bruising doesn't cover the amount of bruising you have."
There's also some pinching going on. The muscles, tissue, and a couple nerves got pulled up into the joint when I fell (or so the doctor said). I start physical therapy soon. :)